Book details
- Author: A.M. SHINE
- Genre: Fiction (Adult) | Horror
- Publication date: 12/02/2026
- Format read: Audiobook
- Narrator: Deirdre O’Connell
- Source: NetGalley
Short verdict
Grace is a gripping psychological horror that pulls you in immediately and refuses to let go. From the opening moments, A.M. Shine establishes an atmosphere of unease that steadily intensifies as the story unfolds. The audiobook format only heightens the experience, making this a compulsive listen that’s difficult to pause. If I had been reading a physical copy, this would firmly fall into “unputdownable” territory.
At a glance
What worked:
- An immediately engaging opening that sets the tone from the outset
- A richly atmospheric setting steeped in isolation and dread
- Strong pacing that sustains tension throughout
- An outstanding narration by Deirdre O’Connell that elevates the story
What didn’t:
- Despite the title, the narrative focus leans more heavily toward Father O’Malley than Grace herself, which may surprise some readers
Final thoughts
Grace is led to the remote island of Croaghnakeela, off the coast of Ireland, by Father O’Malley — a character who ultimately feels more central to the narrative than the title might suggest. Shine excels at setting the scene, painting a vivid picture of an isolated island filled with menace. The sense of place is so strong that the island itself feels like a character, reinforcing the novel’s creeping unease.
The audiobook narration deserves particular praise. Deirdre O’Connell truly brings the story to life, especially in moments of quiet menace. Hearing the warning — “if he sees you, he will follow you” — delivered aloud was genuinely unsettling, and more than once made me question whether I really wanted to go upstairs with the lights off. It’s the kind of narration that doesn’t simply tell the story, but actively deepens the dread.
Shine also does an excellent job of answering the questions the novel raises. The tension builds steadily, but it never feels careless or unresolved. For me, the payoff was satisfying, and the story remained coherent and purposeful right through to the end — something psychological horror doesn’t always manage.
I absolutely loved this book. It’s atmospheric, gripping, and highly effective in audio form, and one I would happily recommend to fans of psychological horror.
Rating
Immersive psychological horror with outstanding narration.
Disclosure
Thank you to Head of Zeus Audiobooks and NetGalley for providing a digital review copy in exchange for an honest review.